This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.

TN: Doctors protest against NEET

TN: Doctors protest against NEET

Chennai: The Doctor’s forum for people’s health  staged a protest on November 20 against the central government-mandated National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test(NEET) for undergraduate and postgraduate medical aspirants.

At a meeting held on Friday, the forum said NEET was a difficult bet for students from rural backgrounds as it is set on the CBSE pattern.  NEET being made a criteria for medical admission was making it difficult for rural aspirants to get admission in medical colleges the forum further added.

“The Tamil Nadu government has firmly been against NEET. It should take action and file a review petition against the Supreme Court order that brought in NEET,” said, General Secretary, S Kasi of the forum told TOI.

The forum  raised the following demands on behalf of Post graduate medical aspirants:

  • a higher quantum of seats for Tamil Nadu students
  • Only 15% seats be made part of the All India Quota( At present 50% allocation)
  • No exit exam for MBBS graduates ( as it demotivates those who aspire to practice in primary healthcare centers and other rural medical facilities)

Every year, Tamil Nadu produces over 5,000 MBBS graduates. The State has one of the highest number of medical colleges in the country with 24 State-run medical colleges (including a college attached to Annamalai University) and an equal number of private/deemed medical institutes, as per the Medical Council of India’s listing.

Up until 2006, Tamil Nadu had its own entrance exam — the Tamil Nadu Professional Common Entrance Examination — for admission to professional courses, both engineering and medicine. In 2007, the State government decided to do away with it, aiming at equitable access to higher education by basing admissions on class 12 results. It is argued by many that NEET, would invalidate Tamil Nadu’s policy.

In Tamil Nadu, the number of students who take the State Board examinations is 60 times more than that of those studying in CBSE stream. Since NEET is based on the CBSE syllabus, Experts have shown concern about how students from the State will fare in the test. Another large concern is that students from other States could get a bigger proportion of seats in government medical colleges in Tamil Nadu.

Source: with inputs
3 comment(s) on TN: Doctors protest against NEET

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. user
    Muthuswami Angamuthu November 22, 2016, 3:45 pm

    We must go with the wind. Change is needed in medical education.

  2. I humbly state that the prevailing procedure for admission into professional courses in Tamilnadu,including MBBS is based on a \” prescribed method \” for normalization and equating method among applicants from different boards and different years of first attempts in qualifying examinations. This existing method adopted for normalization was copied from BITS,pilani and made as a statute called \”Act 3 of 2007,Tamilnadu\”. This adopted method has been declared as unconstitutional & unfair by many courts except Chennai high court,since that is unscientific and arbitrary. Thousands of better meritorious students from Tamilnadu higher secondary board itself from tougher examination years and other tougher board like CBSE,ISC were denied of their fundamental constitutional right for selection due to absurd common merit ranking list in Tamilnadu. In stead,poorly meritorious students are preferred by this unscientific method prescribed by the unconstitutional clause of said ACT. This plea is not against the policy of admission based only on marks obtained in qualifying examination based on a statistically valid normalization and equating. There is no justice prevailing in Tamilnadu admission now.

  3. I fully agree with the observations. We need to raise the standards of UG PG education in the country and for this we need to select entrants based on merit only. Further when we introduce other biases such as reservation based on state boards , local language entance examination Etc we will be lowering the bar and threby the standards which will reflect as poor medical care for the masses Remember the entire syllabus at UG &PG is in English language and this is the parlance of the medical fraternity at large.